"Ready" is a feeling in your boss's head. Here's how to put it there.
The conventional advice is to get ready before you ask. Build the competencies the next job demands, sign up for the training, close the gaps on your résumé, and only after you can honestly say you measure up should you raise your hand. Deserve it, then request it. Many of us absorbed this approach growing up, and the diligence behind it is admirable.
But readiness isn't a fixed quality you carry around that anyone can measure. It's a mental image your manager holds, and the job tends to go to whoever already appears in that image, whether or not they're the strongest candidate on paper.
Yes Readiness is judged by resemblance, not by checklist
When a leadership group in Milwaukee talks about who might move up, nobody reaches for a competency matrix. They picture the person in the seat. Can they see her leading the all-hands meeting, handling the upset client call, presenting to the board? If so, she's ready. If not, she "needs a bit more seasoning," which tells you more about their mental picture than about her record. According to McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 Women in the Workplace study, women in leadership are mistaken for junior staff at twice the rate of their male peers. A room that takes you for a junior person is a room that struggles to imagine you in a senior role.
Also Identical qualifications can look entirely different depending on who is reading them.
Tara Mohr, writing in Harvard Business Review, reported from her survey that women frequently decline openings they feel underprepared for, mainly because they read the posted requirements as non-negotiable. Men, by contrast, usually read that very same posting as an aspirational list. So the woman waits until she satisfies every line, while the man who meets six of ten applies, gets pictured in the role, and gets the offer. Right when she concluded she wasn't prepared, she was in fact better qualified than she gave herself credit for.
Three. The so-called ambition gap turns out to be something other than it seems.
Those same McKinsey and LeanIn findings show that 80% of women seek promotion, against 86% of men, and that once support is distributed evenly, the gap disappears entirely. Women aren't less driven. Women simply receive fewer opportunities to be observed performing the next level's work before it is formally theirs, and it is that observation that shapes how others see them.
Where the old advice still holds in Southeast Wisconsin
Southeast Wisconsin employers still weigh skills heavily. Being promoted into a role you can't actually perform is a glass cliff dressed up in a nice announcement. Data from Russell Reynolds shows female CEOs serve an average of 5.2 years in the post, while men serve 8.1. That's a small sample, but a telling one, and part of the explanation is that women are too often set up to struggle. So prepare. Just don't wait to be noticed until your preparation is complete.
A stronger option
Make yourself visible to decision-makers before the position is advertised. When your manager is out, take charge of the Milwaukee team meeting she normally leads. Once a quarter, brief her senior leadership on a business priority that carries real weight. Then spell out the goal in plain terms, as in: "I want the VP role when it opens." What would you need to see from me between now and then?" The answer becomes your real checklist, and it's usually shorter than the one you drafted yourself. Each month, deliver one high-visibility piece of that role's work in front of the people who will be deciding when the name comes up, whether they sit in Waukesha, West Allis, or downtown Milwaukee.
When Milwaukee's leaders discuss the next VP, is your name a clear picture or just a maybe?